Accueil > Publications > The U.S. Allegations of Improper NAFTA Panel Review in the Softwood Lumber Dispute

The U.S. Allegations of Improper NAFTA Panel Review in the Softwood Lumber Dispute


Initially contained in Chapter 19 of the Canada-United States Free Trade Agreement (CUSFTA), the dispute settlement mechanism for trade remedies (antidumping (AD) and countervailing duty (CVD) cases) of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) is now more than two decades old. While some scholars point to the relative success of Chapter 19 in providing for speedy reviews of either Canadian or American trade remedy determinations and establishing a relatively predictable trade environment for both countries, they also indicate the inherent limits of this chapter despite its binding nature. Some, such as Robert Howse, say that the softwood lumber dispute clearly illustrates such inherent flaws. In fact, the third and fourth episodes of the dispute, known as Lumber III (1991-1996) and Lumber IV (2001-2006), ended in stalemate with both sides unsatisfied with the results. If a binding review mechanism seems adequate for other trade remedy disputes, Softwood Lumber has not been solved through adjudication, but instead through negotiations involving power and diplomacy. With this case in mind, it is not uncommon to hear that Chapter 19 lacks teeth to solve highly litigious trade disputes. Softwood Lumber, thus, has been a real test case for Chapter 19.

(suite dans le document joint)

Partager sur :

Dernières publications


Centre d’études sur l’intégration et la mondialisation (CEIM)
Université du Québec à Montréal
400, rue Sainte-Catherine Est
Pavillon Hubert-Aquin, 1er étage
Bureau A-1560
Montréal (Québec) H2L 2C5 Canada

514 987-3000 poste 3910
Télécopieur : 514 987-0397


Doté d’une structure favorisant la recherche, l’innovation et l’échange des idées, le CEIM réunit des chercheurs de réputation internationale spécialistes de l’économie politique des processus d’intégration et de mondialisation. Les accords commerciaux, la mondialisation, le régionalisme, le pouvoir des firmes, l’impact du numérique, autant de questions qui font l’objet des recherche du centre.

Faites un don

Je donne